Vaccine Mandate Legal Challenges Muddy the Waters for Employers Preparing to Implement Rules

The United States Supreme Court is considering whether to hear a lawsuit on the country’s vaccine mandate. The decision could have wide-reaching implications for employers and other organizations who are working to adopt policies that comply with the law.

The “osha vaccine mandate exemptions” is a legal challenge that has the potential to muddy the waters for employers who are preparing to implement rules.

The deadline for forcing U.S. employees to be vaccinated or tested weekly for Covid-19 is rapidly approaching, but firms are unsure how to effectively prepare because to uncertainty about how legal battles over the requirement would play out.

Those in charge of ensuring that their organizations comply with the Biden administration’s directive will need to be flexible as they execute laws that will take effect on Jan. 4, according to legal and human resource experts.

Private-sector firms with 100 or more employees must verify that their staff are completely vaccinated or take a weekly Covid-19 test and wear a mask at work, according to Occupational Safety and Health Administration standards. For violation, OSHA may levy penalties on businesses. The OSHA emergency temporary standard may be in effect for up to six months before being codified as a permanent standard requiring rulemaking.

The Fifth United States Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans issued an emergency stay earlier this month, stating the guidelines created “grave statutory and constitutional problems.” On Nov. 17, the Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati was chosen at random to hear legal objections to the requirement, and the Biden administration filed an emergency court move on Tuesday demanding the mandate’s immediate restoration.

Around half of the organizations polled by the Society for Human Resource Management indicate that legal challenges to vaccination requirements are preventing them from being implemented. Emily Dickens, SHRM’s chief of staff, head of government relations, and corporate secretary, stated, “The remainder are truly planning for compliance.”

Subscribe to our newsletter

The Wall Street Journal’s Risk and Compliance Journal

Insights and news on governance, risk, and compliance may be found in our Morning Risk Report.

Before the emergency temporary standard, or ETS, was issued, many businesses were already in the process of implementing various types of vaccine requirements, and the emergence of the Delta variant may have accelerated those efforts, according to Kevin Troutman, an attorney at Fisher Phillips and a member of the firm’s Covid-19 task force.

“However, when the president’s announcement…was made public, people were once again seeking to comprehend the rules and begin to apply them,” Mr. Troutman noted.

Experts believe businesses are dealing with a slew of implementation challenges. Companies, for example, must decide how to track and report compliance with the obligation, as well as whether to force staff to get vaccinated against Covid-19 or to enable workers who are vaccine-resistant to test regularly and wear masks at work.

Moreover, despite a clause in the mandate stating that employers are not compelled to give or pay for testing, companies must determine if they should cover the expenses to help retain workers.

“Certainly at this point, before we get too near to the January vaccine deadline…you should be doing all of the back-office things that you’ll need to do to be in compliance,” said Brett Coburn, a partner at the law firm Alston & Bird who specializes in employment disputes and counseling.

However, keeping an eye on the appeals process is critical. “I wouldn’t spend a lot of money on testing or anything else until we know what’s going to happen,” Mr. Coburn said.

RISK & COMPLIANCE JOURNAL: MORE

According to Helene Hechtkopf, a lawyer at the legal firm Hoguet Newman Regal & Kenney LLP who focuses on employment and commercial disputes, how a company’s implementation unfolds will be determined by its size.

“I’ve heard of businesses hiring someone to do testing once a week.” “However, if you have 100 workers and three of them are unvaccinated, it doesn’t make sense,” Ms. Hechtkopf said.

The situation is further complicated by a tangle of state and municipal legislation. Despite the fact that federal law takes priority over state legislation, it is important for companies to understand what additional challenges they may encounter in the jurisdictions where they do business.

This is particularly true when it comes to who will pay for weekly testing, according to SHRM’s Ms. Dickens, who also noted that some towns and states already have their own laws in place, and around one-third of the employers questioned are already intending to fund testing costs.

“Remember, insurance may cover the expense of Covid tests, but there are other statutes that predate Covid that require employers to pay for obligatory medical tests or reimburse their workers for such testing,” Ms. Dickens stated.

According to a Biden administration regulation slated to take effect Jan. 4, large private businesses must guarantee that their employees are vaccinated or tested weekly for Covid-19. Sarah Chaney Cambon of the Wall Street Journal outlines the new guidelines. Susan Walsh/Associated Press photo

Given the widespread opposition to mandates and the lack of information regarding the legal difficulties that lie ahead, industry professionals underline the need of dialogue between businesses and their employees.

“On the one hand, you may say nothing and just be silent and wait to see how things play out in court,” Mr. Coburn said. “On the other hand, you may declare, ‘We don’t care what the courts say; we’re going to adopt an ETS-compliant policy regardless of what the courts say…’ The middle ground is to maintain some kind of contact with your staff while confronting the truth that there is uncertainty.”

The final conclusion, according to experts, is that businesses should plan for any eventuality.

“I believe some corporations have opted to slam on the brakes a bit and watch how this all plays out,” Mr. Troutman said. “However, we strongly advise you to be prepared, at the very least as an employer.” And it includes assessing…vaccinated who’s and who isn’t in your job, at least where you’re able to… If you don’t do at least that much, and let’s suppose the ETS pushes ahead on or near its present pace, you’ll be much behind the curve.”

David Smagalla can be reached at david.smagalla@wsj.com.

Watch This Video-

The “workplace vaccine mandates” is a challenge that employers will face in the future. The mandate to vaccinate employees has been met with legal challenges. This article discusses some of the challenges that employers will face and how they can prepare for it.